Skip to main content

The Thomas Marshall Home, now the home of the Whitley County Historical Museum was built in 1864 by John Rice. It was a large, Italianate, square type two-story frame house. In 1877, Thomas Marshall, who became a prominent lawyer in Columbia City and then on to become Governor of Indiana and Vice President of the United States, purchased the home for himself, his mother Martha and his father Daniel. His father passed away in 1892 and his mother passed away shortly after in 1894.

Thomas Marshall married Lois Kimsey in October of 1895. It was during this time that he remodeled the Marshall home for his new bride. During this remodeling, he installed quarter-sawn oak trim, a fireplace, beautifully paneled pocket doors, paneled doors made of various hardwoods, and parqueted oak floors downstairs. A small 6’x9’ front porch was replaced by its present and much larger porch with double columns years later.

While the Marshalls lived in the home, the front door entered into a centered hall that was 8’ wide by 26’ long. To the right was the parlor which was 12 1/2’ x 16’ and included a bay window. To the left was the library which was 14 1/2’ by 24’ with bookshelves along most of the west wall and a small portion of the east wall. It also had a fireplace in the northeast corner. In the north wall of the library was a large opening into a music room. The 14’x22’ dining room was located at the northeast corner of the house with doors leading into the center hall, the music room, the pantry and kitchen. The kitchen was in the one-story section at the rear of the house. The upper story was divided into a servant’s room in the northwest corner, three large corner bedrooms and one bathroom, all with access to a center hall.

In 1908, when Thomas Marshall became Governor of Indiana, he sold his home to a good friend, Henry McLallen. The McLallen heirs sold the home in 1926. Dr. Pence acquired ownership of the Marshall residence in 1929 and deeded the property to Mrs. Vera Isabelle Pence in 1937. She created several apartments inside the Marshall home as a source of income and in 1963 the property was put up for sale for $12,000.

Prior to 1963, all of the county relics and artifacts were housed on the third floor of the County Courthouse. The Board of Directors met and decided to raise funds and hold a fundraiser to purchase the Thomas Marshall home. The amount of money needed to purchase the home was acquired at the fundraising dinner and the transfer of the property took place in late 1963 with Miss Marguerite Stultz as the first Curator of the museum. The title was then transferred to the Whitley County Board of Commissioners to be held in the name of Whitley County. The Thomas Marshall Home is still home to the Whitley County Historical Museum and is opened year-round, Monday-Friday from 8:00am-4:00pm. Come visit Your Museum!

𝑾𝒉𝒆𝒓𝒆 𝒂𝒓𝒆 𝑾𝒆: 𝑨𝒓𝒄𝒉𝒊𝒕𝒆𝒄𝒕𝒖𝒓𝒂𝒍 𝑯𝒊𝒔𝒕𝒐𝒓𝒚

The columns are of course part of the home of Columbia City’s most widely known resident, Vice President Thomas R. Marshall, at 108 West Jefferson Street.

Originally built in 1874 in the Italianate architectural style popular at the time, the home was remodeled in 1895 at the time of his marriage to Lois Kimsey. It was likely at that time that the house lost some characteristically Italianate features that it would have had, such as decorative eave corbels and cornices, which were replaced with simpler elements. However, even after that and other remodelings, the distinctive low-pitched hipped roof, ornate brick chimney, and substantial porch columns are still evidence of the original style.

After Thomas’ death in 1925, the house remained with his widow until 1953. Eventually it was deeded to the Whitley County Commissioners and has long been the home of the Whitley County Historical Museum. After a renovation to restore its circa 1895 appearance, the home was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1983.

Thank you to Nathan Bilger for providing the recent photos and valuable insights into the architectural history.